Royal Martyrs of Russia

The Holy Royal Passion-bearers Nicholas, Alexandra, Alexis, Olga, Tatiana, Maria and Anastasia

Passion Bearer · King · Queen · Prince · Princess · d. night of 16–17 July 1918 (Julian 3–4 July), at Yekaterinburg

Commemorated 4 July — Killing in the cellar of the Ipatiev house at Yekaterinburg, 17 July — OCA usage, which keeps the civil date of the murder (night of 16/17 July 1918) as the church date

In the cellar of a requisitioned merchant's house at Yekaterinburg, on the night of 16–17 July 1918 — the 4th of July by the church reckoning — the last emperor of Russia, Nicholas II, his wife Alexandra, their four daughters Olga, Tatiana, Maria and Anastasia, and their haemophiliac son Alexis, aged thirteen, were shot together with four of their household. They had been prisoners for sixteen months. The Church honours them not for their politics, on which she pronounces nothing, but for the manner in which they bore captivity and death: without bitterness, at prayer, forgiving, in the pattern of Boris and Gleb — which is what the title passion-bearer (strastoterpets) means and all it means. They were glorified by the Russian Church Abroad in 1981 and by the Moscow Patriarchate at the Jubilee Council of 2000, and are commemorated on July 4. The family's physician, Eugene Botkin, who refused freedom in order to stay with them, is glorified with them.

The persons

  • Nicholas Alexandrovich (b. 1868), emperor from 1894, the last of the Romanov sovereigns.
  • Alexandra Feodorovna (b. 1872), born Alix, princess of Hesse and by Rhine, a granddaughter of Queen Victoria, received into Orthodoxy at her marriage in 1894 and, by all testimony, a convert of unusual intensity.
  • Olga (b. 1895), Tatiana (b. 1897), Maria (b. 1899) and Anastasia (b. 1901), the grand duchesses; the two eldest served as nurses in the military hospitals through the war.
  • Alexis (b. 1904), the tsarevich, a haemophiliac whose illness governed the private life of the family and much of its public misfortune.

Killed with them in the cellar were the physician Eugene Botkin, the maid Anna Demidova, the cook Ivan Kharitonov and the footman Alexei Trupp. Botkin — who had been offered his liberty and answered that he would not leave his patients — was glorified by the Church Abroad in 1981 and by the Moscow Patriarchate in 2016 as the righteous passion-bearer Eugene the physician. The three servants were glorified by the Church Abroad in 1981; the Moscow Patriarchate has not canonised them, on the ground (among others) that Trupp was a Roman Catholic and Demidova a Lutheran.

Abdication and captivity

Nicholas abdicated on 2/15 March 1917, in the collapse of the war effort and of his government, and abdicated also on behalf of his son. What follows is the substance of the Church's case, and it is not political but ascetical. From that moment the family were prisoners: first under house arrest at Tsarskoye Selo, then, from August 1917, in exile at Tobolsk in Siberia, and from April–May 1918 at Yekaterinburg in the Ipatiev house, which their guards called "the house of special purpose."

The regime tightened month by month: the windows whitewashed and barred, the garden walk cut to half an hour, letters read, the guards insolent and frequently drunk, obscenities scratched on the walls. The witnesses to this period — including hostile ones — describe a family that prayed the daily offices together, read the Scriptures aloud, taught the younger children, mended their own clothes, and did not complain. A letter of the Grand Duchess Olga from Tobolsk, written at her father's request, asks that their friends should not attempt to avenge them, "for evil which is now in the world will be yet stronger, but that evil will not conquer evil, only love." A poem copied out in the empress's hand and found among her books at Yekaterinburg ends with the prayer that God would give them strength to forgive their enemies. On 14 July 1918, three days before the end, a priest was allowed in to serve the obednitsa for them; he reported that the deacon, by accident or premonition, sang the prayer "Give rest with the saints" for the departed, and that the whole family fell to their knees.

The night of 16–17 July

Late on the night of 16 July the family were woken, told they were to be moved for their safety, and taken down to a semi-basement room. Chairs were brought for the empress and for Alexis. A detachment under Yakov Yurovsky entered, a paper was read, and they were shot at close quarters; the killing was prolonged and botched, and was finished with bayonets. The bodies were taken by lorry into the forest at Ganina Yama, mutilated, burned and finally buried in a pit at a place called Porosenkov Log.

The Julian date of that night is 3–4 July, and the Church's commemoration is July 4.

Nine days later, on 18 July, the Grand Duchess Elizabeth Feodorovna — the empress's sister, a widow and the foundress of the Martha and Mary convent — was thrown alive down a mineshaft at Alapaevsk with the nun Barbara and other members of the family; her commemoration is July 5, and the two days are read together.

Glorification

Veneration began at once among the Russian emigration and, more quietly, inside Russia. The Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia glorified the family in 1981 among the New Martyrs and Confessors of Russia, together with their four attendants. The Moscow Patriarchate, after long and public deliberation in which the theological objections were fully aired, glorified them at the Jubilee Council of August 2000 — deliberately as passion-bearers and not as martyrs, precisely in order to make clear that the canonisation was of their Christian death and not an endorsement of the reign. The commission's report stated that Nicholas's political acts were not the subject of the act, and that the ground of glorification was the meekness, patience and forgiveness shown in captivity.

The Church on the Blood was built over the site of the Ipatiev house (demolished in 1977) and consecrated in 2003; the monastery of the Holy Royal Passion-bearers stands at Ganina Yama. On the night of the feast a procession of many tens of thousands walks the twenty-one kilometres from the church to Ganina Yama.

Feast and commemoration

July 4 (church date; New Calendar civil July 4, Old Calendar civil July 17 — which is also the civil anniversary of the killing, since the night of 16–17 July 1918 was 3–4 July by the Julian calendar then still in use in Russia). They are kept by the Russian Orthodox Church and by the Russian Church Abroad, and by the Churches that have received those glorifications; they are not on the Greek or Antiochian calendars, and they belong to Phase 1 of this collection only through Russian usage. They are commemorated additionally in the Synaxis of the New Martyrs and Confessors of Russia (the Sunday nearest 25 January) and among the Saints of Yekaterinburg. The day is shared with Andrew of Crete, Andrei Rublev and Andrew Bogoliubsky.

Hymns

Troparion — Tone 4

Today the Russian land brings to Christ her emperor and his household, slain in the night in a cellar: they went down to the slaughter as lambs, praying for their murderers, and were made partakers of the Passion of the Lord. O holy passion-bearers Nicholas, Alexandra, Alexis, Olga, Tatiana, Maria and Anastasia, entreat Christ God to grant our land forgiveness and peace.

Original translation from the Slavonic

Kontakion — Tone 8

Ye did not ask to be avenged, but prayed that evil might be conquered by love; and having nothing left to give, ye gave your death to God. Wherefore we cry to you: rejoice, O royal passion-bearers, who kept the faith in the house of your captivity.

Original translation from the Slavonic

Iconography

The received icon of the Royal Martyrs was fixed at the glorifications of 1981 and 2000 and shows the seven standing frontally in a single row: the emperor at the centre in the plain uniform of an infantry colonel or in the imperial mantle, crowned and haloed, holding a cross; the empress beside him, crowned, in a long mantle; the tsarevich in front or at his father's side in a sailor's or soldier's tunic; the four grand duchesses ranged in order of age in long white or pale dresses, each holding a martyr's cross. Some versions set the family against the Ipatiev house or the forest of Ganina Yama, or place them within the great composition of the New Martyrs and Confessors of Russia, where they stand at the centre beneath the church. Botkin, where he appears, is at the edge in a dark coat.

No image of them can be stored in this collection. Every icon of the Royal Martyrs is a work of the twentieth or twenty-first century and is the copyrighted property of its iconographer; that a photograph of such a panel may be uploaded under a free licence does not free the panel, since the photographer's licence cannot dispose of the painter's rights. Photographs of the family themselves are numerous and many are out of copyright, but a photograph is not an icon and is not stored as one.

Disputed questions

  • Passion-bearer, martyr, or neither? The Church Abroad glorified them in 1981 among the new martyrs; the Moscow Patriarchate in 2000 chose the narrower title passion-bearer, on the classical ground that they were not killed for a confession of faith but accepted an unjust and violent death in a Christlike spirit. This entry follows the 2000 formula, which is the more exact, and records the other. A minority within the Russian Church has pressed for the still stronger language of "ritual murder" or of martyrdom for Orthodoxy as such; the Patriarchate has repeatedly declined it, and this entry does not adopt it.
  • The remains. Remains found at Porosenkov Log in 1979, exhumed in 1991, and identified by several independent genetic studies as those of the emperor, the empress and three daughters, were interred in the Ss Peter and Paul cathedral in St Petersburg in 1998; two further sets, identified as Alexis and Maria, were found in 2007. The Moscow Patriarchate has not recognised the identification, and the state and church investigations have run in parallel for decades; the relics are therefore venerated by many while their authenticity remains formally undetermined by the Church that glorified them. This is an open question and is recorded as one.
  • The attendants. Botkin is glorified by both jurisdictions (by the Patriarchate in 2016); Demidova, Kharitonov and Trupp only by the Church Abroad. A group entry that listed all eleven as glorified would misrepresent both.
  • Number and identity of those commemorated on this day. Some calendars head the day "the Holy Royal Martyrs and those slain with them," others name only the seven. The seven are common to every use.
  • Not to be confused with the martyr-empress Alexandra, wife of Diocletian (April 21), with whom the Tsaritsa Alexandra shares only a name; nor with the great-martyr Anastasia, nor with any of the earlier saints whose names the children bore.

Sources

  1. The acts of the Jubilee Council of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church, Moscow, August 2000 — the glorification of the Royal Family as passion-bearers, and the report of the Synodal Commission for the Canonisation of Saints setting out the grounds and the objections; and the act of the Council of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia, 1981.
  2. The documents of the captivity: the letters and diaries of the emperor and empress from Tsarskoye Selo, Tobolsk and Yekaterinburg; the letter of the Grand Duchess Olga from Tobolsk ("evil will not conquer evil, only love"); the verses copied in the empress's hand; the testimony of the priest who served the obednitsa on 14 July 1918.
  3. The judicial investigation of Nikolai Sokolov (1919–1924) and the later Russian state investigations; the discovery of the burial at Porosenkov Log (1979, exhumed 1991) and of the two further sets of remains in 2007; the interment of 1998 in the Ss Peter and Paul cathedral and the Patriarchate's continuing reservation on the identification.
  4. Russian calendar and synaxarial notices, July 4/17 (azbyka.ru) — Страстотерпцы Николай, Александра, Алексий, Ольга, Татиана, Мария, Анастасия (1918) and Прп. Евгений Боткин (consulted live).
  5. OrthodoxWiki and the standard calendars of July 4 for the form of the commemoration and for the companion memory of the Grand Duchess Elizabeth and the nun Barbara at Alapaevsk (July 5).